Padron 1964 A Maduro Review Limited Edition

A Long, Legendary Smoke Worth Every Second

Let’s start out this Padron 1964 A Maduro Cigar Review with a rarity scale. On a rarity scale of 1-10 this particular Padron cigar sits up comfortably in the top 5. If you’re the type who appreciates a cigar that takes its time—and demands yours—the Padron 1964 A Limited Edition is the real deal. At a long 8.25 inches with a solid 50-ring gauge, this isn’t your average backyard burner. This is a cigar for unhurried nights, deep convos, and a pour of something special.

The Backstory: Legacy Wrapped in Tobacco

Padron doesn’t play when it comes to legacy. Launched in 1994 to celebrate the company’s 30th anniversary, the 1964 Anniversary Series set a new standard for what premium Nicaraguan cigars should be. The “A” size? That’s a limited gem. Only released occasionally and always in small batches, it’s become one of those bucket list sticks for collectors and true cigar heads.

Every cigar in this line is box-pressed, hand-rolled with sun-grown Nicaraguan tobaccos aged a full 4 years, and sealed with a unique double band that fights off counterfeiters. Yeah—it’s that serious.

Flavor Profile: Smooth Powerhouse

From the first spark, you know you’re in for something special. The draw is incredibly easy for the size.

First third hits with a spicy, nutty flavor, think roasted almonds with creaminess.

Midway through, rich cocoa and earthy notes take over, backed by a subtle spiciness that sneaks in just enough pizazz to keep things interesting.

By the final third, you’re deep into leather, espresso, and dark chocolate territory. It’s bold, but smooth—never harsh. The balance is dialed in perfectly. The burn line stays razor-sharp, and the ash hangs on like a champ.

From the Pros: Cigar Aficionado’s Take

Cigar Aficionado awarded the Padron 1964 Anniversary Series “A” a stellar 94 points in their August 1, 2024 issue (Double Corona / 8 ¼″ × 50 )

Cigar Aficionado

Their tasting note highlights: Source Here.

Despite a streaky wrapper and bumpy head, it’s a “delicious smoke.”
Flavor evolves from cocoa and sweet biscuit to dried cherry and licorice.
The 94 score sits neatly in the upper echelon—serious respect from the critics.

Community Buzz: Real Smoker Talk

Trusty voices from the subreddits legit love this blend—not just the “A” size, but the entire 1964 line:

“Got this Padron with a bit of age on it as a gift a while back, super smooth creamy cocoa notes and excellent draw/construction.”
— r/cigar_refuge
Reddit

“A great smoke… Yep, love pretty much anything in the Padrón 1964 series.”
— r/cigars
Reddit

“Chuck is back… Aroma is raisin and dark chocolate with a little more fruit… vanilla, nuts, cream, a little chocolate… In the back third, more pepper comes through with earth and leather.”
— r/cigars
Reddit

The consensus? Flavor complexity, smooth draw, personal favorites all around.

At‑a‑Glance Ratings Summary
Source Vitola Score / Sentiment
Cigar Aficionado 1964 Anniversary Series “A” 94 / 100 – Rich notes of cocoa, cherry, licorice
Online Community Various Padron 1964 Cigar Enthusiastic praise for complexity, smoothness, draw

Pros

✅ Complex Flavor Journey
Starts with creamy cocoa and nuts, evolves into deeper notes of espresso, leather, and spice. Never boring.

✅ Legendary Construction
Padron’s known for quality, and this one proves it. Clean burn, smooth draw, solid ash—no babysitting needed.

✅ Long Burn Time
At 8.25″, this cigar gives you serious value if you’ve got the time. Easily a 2+ hour experience.

✅ Aged Nicaraguan Tobacco
All tobaccos aged 4 years. Smooth as butter with no harshness.

✅ Box-Pressed Beauty
Sleek look, comfy in hand, and that box-press helps the draw stay effortless.

✅ Collector’s Favorite
Limited releases make it a bit of a trophy stick. Ages like fine wine too.

Cons

❌ Not for Quick Smokes
This isn’t a lunchtime stick—it demands time and attention. Not ideal if you’re short on either.

❌ Pricey
You’re paying for quality, no doubt. But at $20–30+ a stick, it’s definitely in “special occasion” territory.

❌ Limited Availability
Being a rare vitola in the 1964 series, it can be hard to find. May require some hunting.

❌ Not Super Beginner-Friendly
The flavor complexity and strength might be a bit much for someone new to cigars.

Padron 1964 A Maduro Review Final Thoughts

From the mag’s 94-point score to the Reddit crowd’s enthusiastic praise (“smooth creamy cocoa,” “complex smoke,” “raisin & dark chocolate vibes”), the Padron 1964 A Limited Edition stands out as a heavyweight in flavor and craftsmanship. Whether you’re loving the tasting notes or just want a cigar that delivers flair and satisfaction, this is the kind of stick that earns its rep—real talk, no BS.